Meeting a potential surrogate brings up a mix of emotions, and it is completely normal for you to feel this way. After all, this is a big step in your surrogacy journey. Think of this as a conversation to build trust and make sure the match feels right.

This guide is here to help you approach that first conversation with confidence. It’s designed to help you make a connection with your surrogate, not as legal or medical advice. 

Why Interviewing a Surrogate Matters

When you are choosing a surrogate, you are not just looking at qualifications on paper. You are choosing someone important to help your family-building journey. That means the match has to feel right and not just check the boxes. Comfort, trust, and mutual respect matter just as much as eligibility. 

That’s why the early conversations between surrogates and intended parents are so valuable. They give you space to talk through expectations, values, and communication styles before the process becomes more emotional and more logistical. 

When you both feel heard from the beginning, it’s easier to avoid misunderstandings later. Think of this first conversation as the start of your relationship. It sets the tone for how you’ll show up for one another.

Setting the Right Tone for the Conversation With Potential Surrogates

The best conversations feel like a two-way exchange, an opportunity to connect and start building trust. Lead with respect and gratitude, and speak honestly about your hopes and concerns, even if the words don’t come out perfectly.

Remember, your potential surrogate is meeting you for the first time, too. She’s listening for your values, communication style, and how you handle sensitive topics. Think of this as a starting point to getting to know each other. Focus on building your relationship. You can let the surrogacy agency and legal professionals discuss the medical and legal details with your potential surrogate. The surrogacy agency you partner with will also handle and coordinate all the important details in your surrogacy journey. Your initial conversation with your potential surrogate should focus on getting to know her, connecting with her, and deciding whether she is a good fit for your family-building goals.

What Questions Should You Ask a Potential Surrogate?

It helps to approach early conversations with potential surrogates with a simple roadmap in mind. You are not trying to cover every detail at once. You are listening for compatibility and shared expectations.

Start by exploring a potential surrogate’s health and lifestyle to understand daily habits and what a supported pregnancy looks like for her. You can talk about her previous pregnancy experience and support needs. You’ll also want to discuss expectations, boundaries, and comfort levels. 

Asking about communication style is important, as well as discussing post-birth thoughts and emotional considerations. This helps everyone begin with a shared understanding of what support might look like after delivery.

Questions About Health, Lifestyle, and Medical History

These questions are meant to help you understand your surrogate’s day-to-day habits, how pregnancy has looked for her in the past, and what kind of support helps her thrive during pregnancy. Keep it warm and curious. These will help you anticipate needs and spot potential challenges early.

Previous pregnancy or surrogacy experiences

Example questions

• What were your past pregnancies like for you, physically and emotionally?

• Were there any complications or unexpected moments you think we should know about?

• If you’ve been a surrogate before, what did you learn from that experience?

• What kind of support felt most helpful during pregnancy?

What to listen for

Listen for openness and ease in how she shares her experience, even when parts of it were challenging. Ideally, she can reflect thoughtfully on what helped her feel supported and what she’s learned about her own needs along the way.

Daily routines and self-care during pregnancy

Example questions

• What does a typical day look like for you right now?

• How do you usually take care of yourself when you’re tired or stressed?

• What habits help you feel healthy and grounded during pregnancy?

• Are there any routines you prefer to keep consistent while pregnant?

What to listen for

Pay attention to whether her routines feel stable and sustainable, and to the practical ways she cares for her body and manages stress. You’re looking for self-awareness and an overall approach that feels balanced, not rigid or unrealistic.

Support systems (family, work flexibility, childcare)

Example questions

• Who is in your day-to-day support system?

• How does your family feel about you pursuing surrogacy?

• How flexible is your work schedule for appointments?

• If you have children, what childcare support do you have when you need rest or appointments?

What to listen for

Listen for realistic plans and stability in her support network. It can be reassuring when the important people in her life understand the commitment and are on board. You’re also looking for practical readiness: how she’ll manage time, energy, and responsibilities when pregnancy demands more.

Comfort with appointments, travel, or activity adjustments

Example questions

• How do you feel about the time commitment of regular appointments?

• Are you comfortable with some travel for care if needed?

• How do you handle changes to routine if pregnancy requires adjustments?

• What would help you feel supported if restrictions or extra appointments come up?

What to listen for

You’re listening for flexibility that comes with healthy boundaries and a willingness to adapt without overpromising. Notice whether she approaches logistics with a collaborative mindset, and whether her expectations feel realistic about the fact that pregnancy can sometimes bring unexpected changes.

Questions About Expectations and Boundaries

Clear expectations and boundaries can reassure both you and your surrogate. Differences are normal, and don’t automatically signal a bad match. The goal is to understand each other early so no one is left guessing later, and to confirm that your comfort levels align.

Talk through what involvement during pregnancy looks like, including updates, milestones, and whether she’s comfortable with your presence at certain appointments. Discuss boundaries around decision-making and personal space, how she prefers to raise concerns, and what support helps her feel stable. 

You can also gently touch on post-birth contact and what feels emotionally healthy and respectful for both of you. Above all, keep the focus on alignment and mutual support.

Example questions

• “What would a supportive relationship with intended parents look like to you?”

• “How involved would you feel comfortable with us being during milestones or appointments?”

• “Are there any boundaries that are especially important for you during pregnancy: privacy, time, visitors, or personal space?”

• “How do you prefer decisions to be discussed if something unexpected comes up?”

Questions About Communication and the Relationship During the Journey

Communication shapes the surrogacy journey, so it helps to talk early about how you’ll stay in touch, share updates, and handle harder moments. Discuss practical preferences, texts versus calls, quick check-ins versus longer updates, and find a rhythm that feels supportive without overwhelming either side.

It’s also important to understand how she handles stress and whether she’s comfortable sharing emotions during pregnancy. Finally, ask what support and respect look like to her. When both sides feel heard and cared for, the relationship starts on a strong foundation.

Example questions

• “What’s your preferred way to communicate (text, calls, email) and what frequency feels supportive?”

• “Do you like quick check-ins, or longer updates at set times?”

• “If something feels off or stressful, how do you usually like to bring it up?”

• “How comfortable are you sharing emotions during pregnancy, and what kind of support feels helpful?”

• “What helps you feel respected and cared for during a big commitment like this?”

What Are Appropriate Questions to Ask a Surrogate?

It’s appropriate to ask your potential surrogate about her pregnancy experience and expectations, including what past pregnancies were like and what she anticipates needing this time around. It’s also helpful to discuss communication preferences. 

You can also ask about support needs and boundaries, such as what helps her feel cared for during pregnancy and what personal boundaries matter to her as she moves through a physically and emotionally demanding experience. 

It’s absolutely appropriate to ask about her motivation for becoming a surrogate, since understanding the “why” can offer meaningful insight into her values, mindset, and readiness for the journey.

What Should You Not Ask a Surrogate?

During this conversation, knowing what to leave out is important, too. The goal is to build trust and mutual respect, and some questions can unintentionally make a surrogate feel uncomfortable. Framing questions appropriately matters. This is about protecting the relationship you’re trying to build.

Avoid intrusive questions about personal finances, as surrogate compensation and logistics are typically handled through the proper channels later. It’s also best to steer clear of political or religious beliefs, which rarely help you assess fit and can introduce unnecessary tension. 

Similarly, don’t push for detailed medical or legal specifics. Those are better addressed later with professional guidance. Skip anything that feels judgmental or prying; when in doubt, ask yourself whether the question helps you build the relationship or risks undermining trust.

How to Prepare for the First Meeting or Call With a Potential Surrogate

Before your first meeting or call, give yourself a little space to prepare emotionally. It’s normal to feel excited and nervous. This conversation matters, which is exactly why it can feel a little vulnerable.

Jot down a few priorities ahead of time, but keep them as themes, not a script. That way, you stay focused without sounding rehearsed. Let the conversation breathe. Pauses are okay, and one call doesn’t have to cover everything. Follow-up conversations and reflection afterward are part of the process.

And remember: nerves are normal for everyone involved. Approaching the moment with patience and openness helps both sides feel more comfortable.

How to Evaluate a Surrogate’s Responses and Know If It’s a Good Match

When you’re listening to a potential surrogate’s answers, focus on how the conversation feels. Openness, honesty, and genuine comfort matter far more than having identical preferences on every detail.

Pay attention to the overall tone. Do you feel at ease asking questions? Does she seem comfortable sharing her thoughts and needs? A good match often shows up in how you communicate, even when topics are sensitive.

After the call, give yourself permission to pause. Reflect on whether the communication felt natural and mutually respectful, and whether you can imagine navigating the ups and downs of pregnancy as a team. This isn’t something you have to decide in the moment. 

Asking the Right Questions With Confidence

Thoughtful conversations create the foundation for trust, and when trust is in place early, there are often fewer surprises later. You don’t need to cover everything at once. The goal is understanding each other while building trust and respect.

A strong match comes down to communication and aligned expectations, especially during emotional or unexpected moments. Remember: you don’t have to do it alone: agency support, counselors, and matching specialists can help you make sense of what you’re hearing and guide next steps. Most importantly, it’s okay to ask questions, revisit topics, and take your time. 

At Growing Generations, we can help you navigate through this process by finding you the right surrogate match.